Clients reviews about Brenz Pizza Co. Clintonville

Cashier that had taken my order was very patient as I was taking a bit to order because it was my first time. The front staff seemed friendly. The manager I think had brought out the food when it was done to me because he saw that me and my wife were taking care of our baby. I appreciated that. The pizza was surprisingly really delicious. The reason I was surprised is usually these little hipster joints are usually ok. The pizzas were cooked perfectly and the sauce was so good. No complaints at all. The wings were not my favorite though. No fault of the cooks or anything just wasn’t a on the same level of the pizza. It was mostly the texture of the wing. Something out of their control. It was cooked great and sauced great. Overall really great. Restaurant extremely clean. Kudos ~ Andrew V

This is my first time trying this pizza place that just opened very recently, and OMG is so good. They have a number of specialty pizzas, but you can also customize your own, which is what I did for 1 of my pies. So fresh, pipping hot, and the flavors marry very well. The pie crust is so soft like a pillow. The restaurant decor is inviting with the smells of fresh baking bread as you walk by and super chill. Seating is available if you need to indulge right now. My husband started eating it his pie in the car. I'm definitely going to be ordering soon. ~ Tameka M

I’ve been here ten times now and feel I am only now qualified to leave a review (having tried all meat, pepperoni, cheese, a classic, bbq chicken, and buffalo chicken). WOW. They haven’t missed yet. We tried different crusts, but their cauliflower crust is incredible. This store is always clean, the staff is always kind, the food is always hot and prepared well, and it is always on time. Also, they don’t make you feel like you have to tip, when you pay you’re never prompted (if you pick up). Try anything, I plan to try them all! ~ Tyson P

First time visiting, but it won’t be my last. We got the Loaded Pep and Cheese and I have to say it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve gotten in Columbus. I liken it to good NYC pizza, but they cut it in squares (which I prefer). Perfect thin (not cracker) crust, perfect amount of delicious sauce, great cheese, and the pepperoni cups were perfectly cooked—not too much and not too little. It’s a bit greasy, so if this bothers you, try a different type. Absolutely recommend without hesitation. ~ Robert D

To be honest this is the best pizza I’ve had when it comes to ordering from a restaurant. Better than the other pizza places around clintonville like pizza house and villa nova. Tastes very similar to a homemade pizza made out of your own kitchen. The crust is the right texture, not too crispy and not too soft. Has a bite to it. Can taste flavor in the crust and all the other toppings. Definitely coming back. Try out their heartland and meatball pizza. ~ Charity :

Tried the Heritage Honey pizza with hot honey drizzle, ricotta, sausage and pepperoni, and it was really good. I went with a garlic butter base just to try something different, and it turned out amazing. The flavors were rich and well-balanced, and everything worked really well together. Also tried the chocolate chip cookie, it was soft in the middle, slightly crispy on the edges, and full of chocolate. So good. ~ Jeena

Stopped by yesterday and I’m seriously glad I did the pizza was incredible. You can tell they care about what they’re serving. Fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and great flavor all around. On top of that, the service was super friendly and welcoming. Jesse and Adam clearly know what they’re doing. Definitely coming back for more. Highly recommend! ~ Jada

Yay! So glad Brenz has opened a location at Graceland. Tonight was training night, and I ordered the Bomber (Garlic butter base, mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese, homemade meatballs, dollops of marinara, Parmesan, finished with fresh basil). It was delicious! They have a not too thin, not too thick crust with a delightful chewiness to it. I will be a regular! Welcome to the neighborhood! ~ Julie D

The pizza at Brenz Pizza co. is fabulous. The stinger pizza with hot honey and jalapeños was so so good. Also, our server Lillian was incredible. She suggested we look at the picture menu which was very helpful, and offered suggestions while we browsed. This was our first experience here and we will definitely return!! ~ iris

SHOUT OUT to the Monday Evening crew. We look forward to the Monday wing special every week, and the team is always personable, speedy, and welcoming. What good people! Best thing about 2025 so far. Thanks for putting the awesome in our week, every single week. ~ miriam a

First time visiting Brenz Pizza Co. and won't be the last. I'm very happy with the food. The pizzas we got had plenty of quality toppings. It could use some decorative touches and a fountain drink system. I think this place was designed more for carryout than dine in. Overall I recommend. ~ Peter G

First time eating at the new Clintonville location. The pizza is fantastic! I had eaten their pizza before a long time ago and remember it being really good, but I had forgotten how good. For me, it's easily in the top 5 pizzas in Columbus. Will definitely be going back!! ~ Harold F

Had a great lunch break at Brenz I ordered the Old world which was recommended by the morning shift workers they are very lovely and very honest which I love! I do plan on coming back soon to order the Brenz Bites and Mushroom Medley overall 10/10 ~ Nyomi L

I had a great time here I’m reading these reviews guys please it’s a great establishment that movie lol that was shown since I was there was Transformers (kid movie btw) please don’t let 1 negative review to stop you from enjoying good pizza ! ~ Christmas T

Absolutely enjoyed my time at Brenz!! Kalli was perfect! she created a hospitable and warm environment and was so nice! The pizza was to DIE for I loved my time at Brenz! Thank you so much for the experience!!! ~ Dezaye H

We had Brenz for the first time today for a staff work event. It was fresh and really good pizza! We all loved it. The cookies were also out of this world. Hoping to order again for work events and myself personally! ~ Geena M

First time trying this place and got a L Heritage Honey. Very good pizza and was delivered on time by a Brenz employee. Will be getting this again. The only change I’ll make going forward is swapping the square cut for triangle cut. ~ Julian S

Welcome to the neighborhood! Brenz has been my favorite pizza shop for a long time now. I'm so glad they have opened a location at Graceland Shopping Center. I just had my personal favorite--the Rustic. Delicious as always. ~ Dan B

I ordered a mushroom medley and A heritage honey the wait time was fair they had a great movie playing me and my kiddo loved it the worker Hannah was the best ~ Sharon S

This is a great slice! Perfectly cooked, fresh toppings, and oh man that crust!!!!!!! Staff is phenomenal! We have a lot of places to choose here in Columbus. Stop looking. GO HERE!!! ~ Andrew W

I thought Pizza house and Tommy's were the best, till I tried Brenz...Fabulous!!! My new fav!!! Lady in front ALWAYS helpful and nice...so good you have to try it!!!! ~ Ms. B

Pizza was amazing, those chocolate brownies are also amazing and huge! My husband loved the red velvet cookies, and my son loved the chocolate chip cookies, which are also huge! ~ Chida F

They haven't opened all the way yet, but had a free VIP training today and gave out free pizza! It was excellent! So glad they are in our neighborhood now! ~ Dave E

Food was so so so good and the cashier who checked us out was sweet and attentive. Shoutout to her - she served the 3 of us and she did a great job. ~ Saige L

Reviews from our customers

Find us on social media